The Lender Wants Me to Buy Back the Contract: Fighting Repurchase Demands Under Your Dealer Agreement
A finance company that bought one of the dealership’s retail installment contracts has sent a letter demanding that the dealership repurchase it. The customer stopped paying, or the credit application was wrong, or the lien was never perfected. The dealer agreement is worth reviewing before the check is written.

What a repurchase provision actually says
Dealer agreements obligate the dealer to repurchase a contract when the dealer breached a specific representation or warranty made at the time of assignment — typically the accuracy of the credit application and deal documents, the perfection of the lender’s lien, the absence of side agreements, and the delivery of title. Most agreements limit repurchase obligations to specific defined conditions rather than a customer default alone. First-payment-default provisions are the exception, and they are usually limited in time.
Common overreach
- Treating a customer’s later default as evidence of fraud at origination
- Demanding repurchase for a lien-perfection failure the lender itself caused by not recording the lien
- Ignoring the cure period the agreement gives the dealer
- Calculating the repurchase price without crediting payments received or the vehicle’s value
- Demanding repurchase after the contractual deadline for making the demand has passed
How to respond
Match every sentence of the demand to a provision of the agreement. Ask the lender for the customer’s payment history and the collateral’s status. If the demand is supported, negotiate the price and structure — a repurchase is sometimes better than a lawsuit from the customer that names both the dealer and the lender. If it is not supported, saying so in writing, with the provisions quoted, preserves indemnification and setoff rights.
Collateral swaps and substitutions
A related dispute arises when a vehicle is swapped on an existing contract — the customer brought the car back and left in a different one, and the lender was told after the fact or not at all. Lien perfection, title, and the RISC itself rarely keep up. These get unwound deal by deal.
The customer’s exposure
If the demand is driven by the customer’s fraud — fake pay stubs, a straw purchase, a misrepresented payoff — the dealership frequently has a claim against the customer for fraud and, where money or property was obtained, civil theft under § 772.11 with treble damages. Repurchasing the contract does not end the analysis; it starts the recovery.
Joshua Feygin, PLLC represents Florida dealers in repurchase and indemnification disputes with lenders, including dealer-lender-vendor disputes and related collections matters. Chapter 679, Florida Statutes (Uniform Commercial Code, Article 9), governs many of the security-interest issues in these agreements, as published by the Florida Legislature. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau also publishes background on installment contract assignments.
This article is general information, not legal advice. It does not address any particular situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and vary by jurisdiction. Businesses with a specific question should consult a licensed attorney in their state.
Joshua Feygin, PLLC represents dealerships and lenders in repurchase and indemnification disputes. Contact the firm.





