Courthouse with columns

FLHSMV Sent My Dealership a Complaint Notice: How the Investigation Works and How to Answer It

A consumer complaint to the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles is different from a demand letter. A demand letter threatens money, while a DHSMV complaint threatens the license. The following describes how the process generally works.

Florida dealership lot subject to an FLHSMV complaint investigation

How a complaint reaches the dealer

Consumers file complaints with the Division of Motorist Services online or through a regional office. The complaint is assigned to a compliance examiner, who sends the dealer a notice describing the allegation — usually a late title, a temporary tag issue, an odometer discrepancy, an unpaid trade-in lien, undisclosed damage, or an advertised-price dispute — and requests a written response and the deal file within a set number of days.

What the examiner is looking for

  • Whether the title application was submitted within 30 days of delivery under § 319.23
  • Whether temporary tags were issued and logged in compliance with chapter 320 and F.A.C. 15C
  • Whether the odometer statement, Buyers Guide, and buyer’s order are complete and consistent
  • Whether any § 501.976 disclosure — dealer fee, pre-delivery service fee, add-on products — was made
  • Whether the dealer has a pattern of prior complaints

What can happen

Most first complaints end with a warning letter or a fine. But chapter 320 authorizes fines of up to $1,000 per violation, and repeated or serious violations lead to an administrative complaint seeking probation, suspension, or revocation of the license. The dealer is entitled to an administrative hearing under chapter 120, including a formal hearing before the Division of Administrative Hearings, before the license is taken.

What a response typically involves

  • A timely, complete written response is generally expected; missed deadlines can be treated as non-cooperation.
  • An organized, complete deal file with a short cover explanation is generally more effective than a partial file.
  • Remediation of the underlying issue — applying for the title, refunding a fee, correcting a record — is a factor examiners commonly weigh, and responses often describe what remediation occurred.
  • Accuracy matters because the response becomes part of the Division’s file and can be obtained by the customer’s lawyer in a later lawsuit.
  • Consistency between the response and any related demand letter or bond claim on the same facts is often a consideration, since inconsistent statements across forums can compound a problem.

The FLHSMV complaint and investigation process is described on the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles website, and chapter 320, Florida Statutes, is published by the Florida Legislature. A complaint sometimes coincides with a demand letter or a bond claim arising from the same transaction.

Regulatory response

An examiner’s visit to the dealership and a request to interview staff are often points where a complaint escalates. Joshua Feygin, PLLC represents Florida dealers in FLHSMV complaint responses, administrative complaints, and DOAH hearings, and in related dealership defense matters. Dealer license defense.

This article is general information, not legal advice. It does not address any particular situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and vary by jurisdiction. Businesses with a specific question should consult a licensed attorney in their state.

Joshua Feygin, PLLC represents dealerships and lenders in FLHSMV regulatory matters. Contact the firm.

Similar Posts